"A Butler Did It" by Robert Scott.
Bonington Players.
The Butler family is congregating to attend the funeral of their aunt, Francesca Bloom, who doesn't seem to have been the most popular member of the family. But what you see may not be quite as it seems!
There's a lot of manipulation from some of the characters and what "whodunnit" play would not be complete without a few twists thrown in for good measure? But can we really believe that a Butler did do it, or was it someone else......?
Andrew Butler is a movie star who has done well for himself in Hollywood but has a shady secret, which is revealed not too far into the play. Played by Christian King, we first see him being interviewed by the police in a smart black suit complete with dark glasses, an image to match his "superstar film star" status. As the play goes on, we discover that he's not entirely happy with his life, even though he has just remarried and has returned from his honeymoon. Christian is an excellent comedy actor, but in this role we also see how good he is portraying a villain; but that's not say that his character is guilty of first degree murder....or is he?
Kimberley Butler is Andrew's wife. They have just come back from what at first seems like an idyllic honeymoon, straight off the plane, straight to the home of the late Francesca Bloom. Played by Charlotte Hukin, who delivers a marvellous upper-class accent and shows a privileged air, well after all, she has married into money. But money is not all that she wants from this family.......
Kimberley Butler is Andrew's wife. They have just come back from what at first seems like an idyllic honeymoon, straight off the plane, straight to the home of the late Francesca Bloom. Played by Charlotte Hukin, who delivers a marvellous upper-class accent and shows a privileged air, well after all, she has married into money. But money is not all that she wants from this family.......
Freddie Butler is Andrew's brother. Freddie has gambling issues and we find that he owes quite a bit of money to some heavies, who are in a rush to get the debt paid. His wealthy film star brother has agreed, again, to help him out of his hole by providing him with the million he needs to clear the debt. But the debt is not the only issue Freddie has! Eddie Januszczyk plays Freddie, and as usual, we get a perfectly pitched comedy performance. His scene later in the play with the housekeeper/maid is a fantastic physical farce fest.
Colin Butler is Andrew's other brother and is a nervous wreck. Andrew Goodfellow-Swaap, a newcomer to Bonington Players, plays Colin, who states from the moment he comes out of the closet, literally, that he does not feel at all comfortable being in the same room as his brothers, and we find out why very quickly. Andrew does awkward very well, which is just as well because Colin finds himself at the centre of some really awkward situations. Andrew is a relative newcomer to the stage but this doesn't come through with the confidence shown by Andrew. I'd just suggest a little more projection in places, but the volume provided could also be interpreted as Colin's nervousness in the situations he finds himself in, but as a debut, this is good.
Ester Butler is Colin's wife and played by Lindsey Hemingway. Ester has to take charge of her husband on more than one occasion; the character is a strong one and Lindsey shows that strength brilliantly, but then again Lindsey is a very strong actor who is used to delivering strong characters to the stage.
Sally Ann Dowling is an eccentric, confused maid who mixes up her words and is there to make sure that the funeral guests are well catered for, maybe over catered. Francesca had left Sally Ann in charge of the proceedings for the funeral, maybe because she has been in service for Francesca for a long time. Several smaller comic scenes for Gennie Price, who plays Sally Ann, but the scene in her work out gear, complete with Olivia Newton-John's "Physical" in the headphones exercise to is a scene that made me smile. Just a while later she finds another way to destress with a member of the gentry!
Jasper King Jr is the aged Butler, who like Sally Ann, has been in service to the Blooms and The Butlers for many, many years. Wayne Hill plays Jasper with brilliant physicality, slowly moving from one side of the stage to the other is comedy gold in itself. I've witnessed quite a few of Wayne's stage characters over the years, and this is one of his best comic roles.
Francesca Bloom is played by Anne McCarroll, and I think you may have surmised that if Bonington Players have cast an actor of the quality of Anne, in her debut with the group, then the role must be more than that of a corpse. You would be right and I don't think that I'm giving anything away to say that this is the first of many surprising twists in this play.
Inspector Bridge is the detective on the case along with Inspector Henderson, who is the more enthusiastic of the pair. Played by Des Fitzpatrick and Zoe Lander respectively, this pair are well matched in the casting. Bridge is a typical East End copper who plays the "bad cop" role with Henderson being more of the "good cop" figure. The scene with Henderson interviewing Colin though is a comedy masterpiece, obviously written by a comedy mastermind, but I won't spoil it by saying why - go and see it.
Dawson is a brief that is assigned to the case. She has a bit of a crush on the famous Andrew Butler, and the fact that she gets text or WhatsApp messages from her mother, complete with emojis ensures that the timeline of the story remains modern. Played by Joanne Smith, who also makes her debut for the Bonington Players.
Directed by Chris Gardner and Billy Bamberger, this production is one of the funniest farces - even though a farce is supposed to have five doors, who cares the set is two doors short. The first act gives not a lot away, and having never heard of this play, never mind seen it previously, you're at the mercy of the cast to feed you the information, and they do that brilliantly. I had no idea at all what was to happen in the second act and though to myself of what the possibilities could be. My guesses were nowhere near what actually happens! As of the end of the first act, we had no lifeless bodies, but after the start of act two........
Sound and lighting design is by David Goatham and Sound Operator being Robin Davis with the lighting operated by one of the theatre technicians. Some well timed sound effects and an explosion that made a few people jump!
The set has been designed by Howard Whitehurst. The set is predominantly taken up by the living room of Francesca Bloom, but there's a little space, highlighted by the lighting, which shows an interview space in the police station. One of several things that I always look forward to with the Bonington Players are the set designs. This is no different, the set is perfect, the sort of room I could see myself living in myself. Howard's knowledge of design is second to none, as shown here. The set dressing is thanks to Linda Whitehurst.
Construction of the set is by Steve Atkin, Carol Hill, Nick Hill, Neil Lylack and Gareth Morris.
Stage managed by Luke Richardson, assisted by Nigel Kenton and Gail Tomlinson.
Many people will only go and see plays that they know, but I love seeing plays that I have never seen or heard of before. Sometimes it's a bit of a gamble, but in the case of this one, it's a gamble that I would wager will not leave anyone disappointed. It's one of the funniest murder mystery comedies that I have seen ever, which makes me wonder why it's a play that is not performed more often. I guarantee that you will leave with a smile on your face.
Another big success for The Bonos, thanks to a great choice of play, wonderful cast, great make up and costumes, and perfect Production team. Also watch out for their next play in January called "The Tin Woman"
"A Butler Did It" is being performed by Bonington Players at Bonington Theatre, Arnold until Saturday 17 October. It'll be a crime to miss this one.


































